10. Summoner 2
Summoner 2 is a hidden RPG gem that many have slept on. The game picks up after the events of the first Summoner, and the combat system is improved, offering a much smoother experience. With a richer narrative, expanded world-building, and deeper character development, this game is one of the most underrated RPGs of its time. If you're looking for an underrated fantasy epic to dive into, look no further than Summoner 2.
9. Tombi 2

It’s no surprise that Tombi 2 makes the list—this quirky platformer is charming, fun, and packed with personality. The game improves on the original with greater variety in levels and mechanics, offering an even more engaging experience than its predecessor. Sadly, Tombi 2 never got the recognition it deserved, and the lack of a remaster or port leaves it as a forgotten classic. If you loved the first, Tombi 2 is an essential sequel that brings even more adventure and weirdness to the table.
8. Final Fantasy 10-2
Many people sleep on Final Fantasy 10-2, but it’s honestly one of the most innovative and fun sequels in the Final Fantasy series. The game introduces a fast-paced, job-based combat system, giving players the ability to switch between classes mid-battle for dynamic action. It’s lighthearted, filled with catchy tunes, and presents an empowering story that stands in contrast to the often somber tones of its predecessor. This sequel deserves much more credit for what it brought to the table.7. Parappa the Rapper 2
Who could forget the groovy beats and colorful charm of Parappa the Rapper 2? As the follow-up to the beloved rhythm game, Parappa 2 not only retains the silly fun of the original but also adds new mechanics and expanded features. The game keeps the series’ core appeal—its catchy music, adorable characters, and wacky scenarios—while enhancing the rhythm-based gameplay to make it an even more enjoyable experience. A sequel with so much heart that didn’t get enough attention.6. Prototype 2
Taking the chaotic world of Prototype to a whole new level, Prototype 2 delivers an even larger scale of destruction. Playing as James Heller, a character with all-new powers and a darker story than the first game, players are given the freedom to wreak havoc in an open-world setting. The game might not have been as universally praised as its predecessor, but the improved combat, thrilling narrative, and expansive environments make it a must-play for action game lovers.5. True Crime: New York City
True Crime: New York City is one of those open-world games that is often overlooked despite being an absolute underrated gem. Offering players the opportunity to play as both a good cop or bad cop, the game delivers a deep crime narrative set in a beautifully crafted New York City. The action-heavy gameplay, choices that affect the story, and ability to truly explore the gritty underworld make it a forgotten classic in the open-world genre.4. Watch Dogs 2
Watch Dogs 2 took the controversial first game and flipped the script, offering a fresh, more playful tone with Marcus Holloway leading the charge. The game introduced expanded hacking mechanics, a more vibrant open world, and a sense of freedom that was previously lacking. It didn’t get the commercial success it deserved, but it’s a standout sequel that improved upon almost every aspect of the original. Watch Dogs 2 is sleek, clever, and undeniably fun—a sequel worth celebrating.3. NBA Street V3

One of the greatest sports games of all time, NBA Street V3 takes the iconic series and expands it, delivering even more stylish basketball action with over-the-top moves, sick customization options, and a killer soundtrack. The game’s aesthetic and gameplay make it a high point in the NBA Street series, yet it’s underrated when compared to other sports games. V3 is a must-play for anyone who enjoys a good, fast-paced, and flamboyant street basketball game.
2. Street Fighter 3: Second Impact
Street Fighter 3: Second Impact is a hidden gem in the Street Fighter franchise, offering technical depth, new characters, and polished gameplay that rivals even the most legendary fighters. Building on the foundations of Street Fighter 3: New Generation, this sequel introduces an even more dynamic combat system, greater character variety, and perfects the balance of speed, precision, and strategy that fans love. While Third Strike often gets the attention, Second Impact is undeniably underrated and deserves more recognition.
1. Mafia 3

If you’re looking for the ultimate underrated sequel, look no further than Mafia 3. The game delivers an incredible and immersive narrative that feels like a living movie, set in a beautifully realized post-Vietnam War New Orleans. The story follows Lincoln Clay, a man seeking revenge against those who wronged him. The game’s cinematic story, open-world freedom, and attention to detail make it stand out in a genre filled with great titles. Mafia 3 is simply outstanding and remains one of the most underrated sequels in gaming history.
Tags:
video games