The PlayStation 5 has an impressive library of blockbuster titles, but not every great game gets the attention it deserves. While some titles dominate headlines and sales charts, others fly under the radar, offering incredible gameplay, engaging stories, and unique experiences that go overlooked.
In this article, we shine a spotlight on 20 of the most underrated PlayStation 5 games. Each of these titles is a hidden gem in its own right, waiting to be discovered and appreciated by players looking for something off the beaten path. From inventive indies to ambitious big-budget releases, these games deserve your attention—and here's why.
Top 20 Most Underrated PlayStation 5 Games
20. Destruction AllStars
.webp)
A unique vehicular combat game that combines high-octane action with character-driven strategies, Destruction AllStars had the potential to be a smash hit. Unfortunately, a lack of marketing and confusion over its release model left many players unaware of its existence.
Despite this, it delivers exhilarating multiplayer chaos with a roster of vibrant characters, each with unique abilities that add depth to the gameplay.
The thrill of wrecking opponents in high-speed arenas, combined with the ability to go on foot and sabotage vehicles, offers a fresh twist on the genre. For fans of games like Rocket League and Twisted Metal, this is an underrated gem that deserves more love.
19. Ni no Kuni II: Revenant Kingdom
While the original Ni no Kuni garnered significant attention for its Studio Ghibli-inspired art and heartfelt story, its sequel slipped through the cracks despite its numerous improvements.
Ni no Kuni II builds on its predecessor with an engaging kingdom-building mechanic that lets players develop their own realm while embarking on a touching adventure.
The combat system is dynamic and fast-paced, offering plenty of variety with unique party members and magical Higgledies. Its stunning visuals and endearing characters make it a standout RPG, but the lack of major promotion has left it underappreciated by mainstream audiences.
18. KLONOA Phantasy Reverie Series
This remastered collection brings back the charm of Klonoa: Door to Phantomile and Klonoa 2: Lunatea’s Veil, two beloved platformers that didn’t get the recognition they deserved in their original releases. The whimsical levels, clever puzzle-platforming gameplay, and emotional storytelling make this series a delight for both newcomers and longtime fans.
The updated graphics and quality-of-life improvements make it accessible for modern audiences, yet its nostalgic roots may have caused it to be overlooked in favor of newer titles. If you’re a fan of classic platformers with heart, Klonoa’s adventures are worth revisiting.
17. Creed: Rise to Glory
As a VR boxing game, Creed: Rise to Glory offers an immersive experience that puts players in the shoes of a professional boxer. Despite its thrilling and authentic gameplay, the niche appeal of VR gaming has kept it from reaching a broader audience.
Players can train, spar, and climb the ranks in a cinematic career mode that ties into the popular Creed film series. The motion controls and realistic physics make every punch feel satisfying, while the intense matches demand quick reflexes and strategy. It’s a hidden gem for VR enthusiasts looking for an adrenaline-pumping workout.
16. Shantae and the Seven Sirens
The Shantae series has always been a cult favorite, and Seven Sirens is no exception. Combining vibrant visuals, fluid animations, and engaging Metroidvania-style gameplay, it’s a treat for fans of platformers. However, its release was overshadowed by bigger AAA titles, causing it to be overlooked.
The game’s humor, charming characters, and catchy soundtrack make it an absolute joy to play. The ability to transform into various creatures adds layers of strategy to exploration and combat, ensuring there’s always something new to discover. It’s a colorful, lighthearted adventure that deserves to shine brighter.
15. Streets of Rage 4
A love letter to fans of the classic beat-‘em-up genre, Streets of Rage 4 modernizes the formula with stunning hand-drawn visuals and fluid combat mechanics. Despite critical acclaim, it didn’t reach the same popularity as other retro revivals.
The game’s co-op mode is a blast, whether you’re teaming up locally or online, and the roster of characters offers unique fighting styles to master. Its soundtrack, filled with nostalgic and modern beats, complements the high-energy action perfectly.For anyone seeking a polished and satisfying arcade experience, this title shouldn’t be missed.
14. Immortals of Aveum
Blending first-person shooter mechanics with a rich fantasy setting, Immortals of Aveum is a bold experiment that didn’t get the recognition it deserved. Players wield powerful magic instead of traditional weapons, creating a unique combat experience that feels fresh and exciting.
The world-building is impressive, with a detailed lore that draws players into its mystical universe. Unfortunately, its release amidst high-profile titles caused it to be overlooked. If you’re looking for something innovative with breathtaking visuals and fast-paced gameplay, Immortals of Aveum is worth exploring.
13. Thunder Ray
A retro-inspired boxing game with striking pixel art, Thunder Ray is a hidden gem that captures the essence of arcade classics like Punch-Out!! Its fast-paced gameplay challenges players to learn enemy patterns and time their punches perfectly, resulting in highly rewarding victories.
Despite its charm, the indie nature of the title has kept it under the radar. With its quirky character designs, intense boss battles, and satisfying combat mechanics, Thunder Ray offers a nostalgic yet modern twist on a beloved formula.
12. Horizon Forbidden West
Though widely praised, Horizon Forbidden West’s release was overshadowed by Elden Ring, leading it to be unfairly underappreciated. This sequel expands on the first game’s foundation with a richer open world, deeper character interactions, and improved combat systems.
The game’s story explores complex themes of humanity’s survival and technological advancements, making it both thought-provoking and emotionally engaging. Its lush environments and mechanical beasts are a visual marvel, ensuring that every moment feels epic. Fans of action-adventure games owe it to themselves to dive into Aloy’s journey.
11. Alan Wake 2
Building on the cult classic, Alan Wake 2 doubles down on its psychological horror roots while introducing innovative gameplay mechanics. The atmospheric storytelling and haunting visuals create a gripping experience that lingers long after the credits roll.
However, its focus on a niche genre and tough competition from other AAA titles have kept it from widespread success. Fans of narrative-driven games and eerie mysteries will find this a deeply rewarding adventure.
10. Dead Island 2
After years of delays, Dead Island 2 finally delivered a chaotic zombie-slaying experience with a dose of dark humor. Its dynamic combat system lets players creatively dispatch hordes of undead using an arsenal of weapons and environmental traps.
The game’s vibrant, sun-soaked setting contrasts with its gruesome content, making it both horrifying and entertaining. While its development struggles may have dampened expectations, the final product is a blast for fans of co-op survival games.
9. Assassin's Creed III: Remastered
This remaster breathes new life into one of the most ambitious entries in the Assassin’s Creed series. Set during the American Revolution, the game’s historical backdrop and complex protagonist, Connor, make for a compelling narrative.
The updated graphics and gameplay refinements enhance the experience, but it remains overshadowed by other entries in the franchise. Its focus on large-scale battles and intricate story elements make it a standout adventure worth revisiting.
Meanwhile Assassin's Creed: Liberation, originally released on the PlayStation Vita, is an often overlooked gem in the Assassin's Creed series. While it might not have the same recognition as Assassin's Creed III, Liberation introduced players to Aveline de Grandpré, the first female protagonist in the main series.
Set in 18th-century New Orleans during the French and Spanish colonial period, the game blends the series' signature parkour and stealth mechanics with a compelling storyline about freedom and identity.
The remastered version on PS5, allowed a new generation of players to experience Aveline's journey. Her unique abilities and the immersive setting make Liberation a worthy entry in the Assassin’s Creed franchise, offering a refreshing change of pace for those looking for something different.
8. Need for Speed Unbound
Injecting a fresh sense of style into the franchise, Need for Speed Unbound combines cel-shaded visuals with high-stakes street racing. The game’s robust customization options and emphasis on underground racing culture make it a standout entry.
However, its unique aesthetic may have divided fans, causing it to be overlooked. For those craving fast-paced action and vibrant visuals, this title delivers an exhilarating ride.
7. The Walking Dead: The Final Season
The emotional conclusion to Telltale’s beloved series offers some of the most impactful storytelling in gaming. Following Clementine’s journey as she navigates a post-apocalyptic world, the game explores themes of survival, sacrifice, and growth.
Its gripping narrative and meaningful choices make it a must-play, but the studio’s financial troubles during its release caused it to fly under the radar. Fans of story-driven games will find this a deeply moving experience.
6. Season: A Letter to the Future
Season is a meditative exploration game that invites players to document a world on the brink of change. Its focus on introspection, stunning art direction, and thought-provoking themes set it apart from traditional action-packed titles.
Unfortunately, its slower pace and unconventional gameplay style may have deterred some players. For those willing to embrace its reflective nature, Season offers a unique and emotionally resonant journey.
5. Tales of Kenzera Zau
4. Mafia III: Definitive Edition
Set in a richly detailed version of 1960s New Orleans, Mafia III’s story of family and revenge is both gripping and emotionally charged. The Definitive Edition enhances the experience with improved visuals and all DLC included. While initial technical issues hurt its reputation, the game’s compelling narrative and atmospheric setting make it a hidden gem worth exploring.
3. Flintlock: The Siege of Dawn
Flintlock blends action and adventure in a fantastical setting, offering a unique combat system that combines melee and ranged attacks. Its rich lore and stunning visuals create a captivating world to explore, but its release was overshadowed by bigger titles. For those seeking an innovative and visually striking adventure, Flintlock delivers.
2. Saints Row Reboot
The Saints Row reboot offers a fresh start for the series, focusing on chaotic sandbox gameplay and a diverse cast of characters. While it faced criticism for its tonal shift, the game’s humor and over-the-top action remain true to the franchise’s spirit. It’s a fun and irreverent experience for fans of open-world mayhem.
1. Forspoken
This magical open-world adventure combines stunning visuals with fast-paced, spell-based combat. Forspoken’s unique parkour traversal system lets players fluidly navigate its expansive environments, creating a sense of freedom rarely seen in open-world games. Despite mixed reviews, its heartfelt narrative and innovative gameplay mechanics make it a standout experience for those willing to give it a chance.